BIG TRENDS + TAKEAWAYS FROM BECKER'S 21ST ANNUAL ASC/ SPINE CONFERENCE 

ASCs and Private Practice

Hear from Our Speakers

"We look at it as a partnership with hospitals because you can't do without hospitals — there are still patients that do not meet criteria to be served or operated on in the ASC world." 

John Russell, director of area operations for seven of Sutter Health's 36 ASCs in Northern California

 "Before your facility's accreditation, look at whether higher compliance with the standards showed an increase in quality of care. You can do a lot of benchmarking with that as well."

Jen Pagel, MSN, RN, quality manager, OAM Surgery Center at MidTowne (Grand Rapids, Mich.)

"In my discussions with payers, when you really peel back the onion — yes, they want cheaper, better, faster — but their goals are really about mitigating risk. They want predictability, especially in spine."

Ronjon Paul, MD, chairman of spine surgery at Duly Health and Care (Downers Grove, Ill.)

5 Big Trends

Increase in Outpatient Procedures: ASCs are seeing a spike in outpatient procedures, driven by advancements in minimally invasive techniques and a shift toward value-based care. This trend is reducing the need for hospital admissions and promoting patient convenience without compromising quality.

Amid these changes, several leaders in panel discussions underscored the importance of hospital and ASC collaboration. John Russell, director of area operations for seven of Sutter Health's 36 ASCs in Northern California, said he's approaching the trend from the lens of what best serves the patient.

"We look at it as a partnership with hospitals because you can't do without hospitals — there are still patients that do not meet criteria to be served or operated on in the ASC world," Mr. Russell said during a discussion on financial growth opportunities for orthopedics, spine and pain management. "So where we're coming from, some of my centers are not in a place where we have a Sutter hospital, so we've partnered with those local hospitals to make sure the patient is at the right place. So it's a collaboration; it's not hospitals against ASCs. We do need both." 
 

Hospital Partnerships and M&A: The trend toward consolidation and hospital partnerships for ASCs is driven by the need for integrated care, cost efficiencies and enhanced patient outcomes. These partnerships allow ASCs to leverage hospital resources, technology and expertise, providing high-quality surgical care in a more convenient and cost-effective outpatient setting. 

In a discussion on M&A activity, Dr. Yadhati of Ortho Rhode Island described the benefits of mergers he's seen professionally and organizationally. "Because of that process of coming together and being able to create that strength in numbers, we've exploded our outpatient arthroplasty volume," he said. "Spine's next to come online, once we get some of the capital equipment we're hoping to have to support that process as well. So I'm super fortunate that I latched myself on the group back when I was a fellow. The growth story has been tremendous just as part of that merger."

Regulatory and Compliance Challenges: Navigating the complex landscape of healthcare regulations remains a significant concern. Compliance with Medicare's stringent requirements, payer contracts and local healthcare laws is critical, demanding ongoing effort and resources from healthcare providers. Noncompete bans are also affecting ASCs, possibly allowing more surgeons to leave the hospital for ASC ownership. But ASCs may also see an uptick of surgeons and staff exiting for other centers.

In a panel discussion that covered strategies for acing ASC accreditation and strengthening care quality, leaders discussed the critical role of staff satisfaction, as well as benchmarking, to retain ASC staff and ensure compliance standards are met. 

"Transfer rates, infection rates, staff satisfaction — if you're meeting the standards, you're probably doing alright in those areas," LoAnn Vande Leest, RN, interim executive director, The Orthopaedic Surgery Center said. 

Jen Pagel, MSN, RN, quality manager, OAM Surgery Center at MidTowne (Grand Rapids, Mich.) added to Ms. Vande Leest's comments, urging leaders to look at peer sites' performance for comparison and goal setting. 

"Just looking at those indicators of care quality relevant to the accreditation standards and patient outcomes that could be affected by the standards — so infection rates, adherence to the different clinical guidelines, adherence to the facility requirements — and you can benchmark with other sites that have the same accreditation," Ms. Pagel said. "Before your facility's accreditation, look at whether higher compliance with the standards showed an increase in quality of care. You can do a lot of benchmarking with that as well."

Payer Policy Updates: Reimbursement trends for ASCs increasingly favor value-based care models, emphasizing cost efficiency and patient outcomes. Payers, including Medicare and private insurers, are gradually adjusting reimbursement rates to reflect the lower costs and high-quality care provided by ASCs compared to traditional hospital settings. But many ASCs also report more denials, preauthorizations and other barriers to providing efficient care.

Dr. Bruggeman of Texas Spine Care Center noted a specific denial trend he's seeing across orthopedic groups. "In speaking with orthopedic groups across the country on a regular basis, the biggest thing we're hearing is site-of-service denials," he said.

He described how this trend often creates a patient-surgeon "limbo" and general uncertainty about where and how the surgeon will perform the case in a way that won't delay care nor increase the complexity of the denial. 

"It's significantly changing the dynamics of the healthcare systems," Dr. Bruggeman said. At his own practice, Dr. Bruggeman is also seeing partial denials, where payers will deny one of multiple codes submitted for a procedure. 

"So then you're stuck in a quandary — you have a patient who is eligible to get the surgery done, but do you really want to go in and fight and delay this process further to try and get paid for all of the procedures you're going to do? Or do you just kind of bite the bullet and get paid 75% of what you were going to get paid?" he said.
 

Cost Containment and Efficiency: Cost control is increasingly important amid rising healthcare expenditures. Practices are employing lean management techniques, optimizing resource utilization and adopting financial management software to maintain profitability while delivering high-quality care.

Shannon Cameron, COO of AFS, a subsidiary of Harvard Medical Faculty Physicians (Boston), noted her organization's financial strategy has centered on the notion of learning to do more with less.

"One of the things we've done over the past few years, which of course was forced upon us through COVID, is moving to a remote staff [for administrative functions]. That's been an enormous cost savings for our organization," Ms. Cameron said in a panel discussion. "Our lease was up for the billing center last October, so I was able to meet with the architect and we reduced overhead by 50%. So that was a huge cost savings. So we're looking inward, where can we make those changes? We're a teaching organization, so anytime we have a profit in our organization, that goes back into research; it goes back into training and it helps with supplementing the grant money that our organization receives. So we're highly motivated from that perspective, but also there's a continual understanding and culture of transparency in those cost savings."
 

M&As

Merger and acquisition activities in ASCs and private practices have surged in the last few years, driven by the quest for operational efficiencies, cost reduction and enhanced bargaining power with payers. Key trends include increased consolidation among smaller practices to gain scale, integration of ASCs into larger health systems to broaden service offerings and the rising interest of private equity firms in these assets.

AJ Mencias, MD, president, South Bend (Ind.) Orthopaedics and Sports Medicine and orthopedic surgeon, Allied Physicians Surgery Center (South Bend, Ind.), described the benefits his organization has seen in its partnership with OrthoAlliance, a private equity-backed management services organization.

"Contract negotiations, when they have scale, when they have 200 doctors and they cover a lot of lives, become compelling on our side to talk to payers," Dr. Mencias said. "The other thing is we wanted a more robust way to run our business; it's not mom and pop. When I joined we had 10 partners, 60 employees. Now, it's four or five times as large. And I can tell you when you negotiate with hospital systems, which is a partnership, you should do work with AI and private equity-backed business companies. It's better to be part of a larger organization. And when hospital systems recruit orthopedic surgeons, it's well known that they overpay." 

While these consolidations can yield significant financial and strategic benefits, healthcare leaders must navigate potential concerns including regulatory scrutiny, cultural integration challenges and the potential loss of personalized patient care that smaller, independent practices often provide. Ensuring compliance with antitrust laws and maintaining quality of care amid rapid changes remain critical priorities in this dynamic healthcare landscape.

In a panel discussion that explored whether spine and orthopedic ASCs can remain independent, Curtis Mayse, CEO, Steamboat Orthopaedic & Spine Institute (Steamboat Springs, Colo.), said his outlook for the independent ASC market is positive — though there are myriad considerations for practice leaders that cannot be taken lightly. 

"It still needs proper management and oversight because implant costs still go very high," Mr. Mayse said. "But the independent ASCs absolutely are in favor, assuming they can be managed well, stay in business and keep the right cases. And it's always the issue of you bringing in robots or not and all those aspects that are high-cost items."

Outlook for the next 5 years

Healthcare leaders must be prepared to manage increasingly complex cases in the ASC by investing in state-of-the-art facilities and ensuring they have the skilled workforce necessary for those procedures. Moreover, the emphasis on patient experience will necessitate continuous innovation in patient engagement strategies, incorporating feedback mechanisms and implementing technologies that streamline the patient journey from pre-admission to post-discharge.

In a panel discussion on orthopedic practice growth in the next five years, Ronjon Paul, MD, chairman of spine surgery at Duly Health and Care (Downers Grove, Ill.), emphasized the importance of patient experience amid consolidation.

"Especially in spine, even if you're part of a group that's 110 physicians or a few hundred, right now we have five spine surgeons," Dr. Paul said. "So we really behave like a small office, a small group practice, but we realized we're going to have to scale more and more and bring those concepts that we're learning from ourselves and also our partners that are in PM&R and anesthesia. We want to build that integration in a way that's much larger and much more scalable. And that's really what I've been trying to build over the last year and a half." 

And some leaders are "going back to basics" when it comes to connecting with and serving patients, proving it's not just technology that can make an impact on experience. Heather McFarland, DO, system director, Anesthesia Value Network and vice chair of clinical operations, University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center, described how her organization's perioperative space, including ASCs, has seen great success in the enhanced recovery after surgery program with personalized, pre-surgery care kits that are sent to patients' homes.

The care packages include carb-loading drinks to help patients get ready for their surgery; a pedometer to encourage them to get in steps prior to their procedure; an incentive spirometer to make sure the patient is breathing well; and more — all with the aim of improving pre- and post-surgical outcomes.

"What's interesting is these kits cost $38," Dr. McFarland said. "We somehow talked all of the leadership into paying for these kits, so it isn't a cost to the patient. We had to develop that during COVID because no one was going into the stores to buy these things. So we were packing it up and sending it to them. So, that's been, I think, a place where you can really be creative and inventive as you're trying to work with your patients."

Regulations will become even more stringent, with added layers of compliance particularly around data security and patient privacy. This regulatory environment will drive the adoption of more robust EHR systems and cybersecurity measures. Leaders will need to stay abreast of these changes, ensuring their practices comply with the latest standards to avoid penalties and ensure the trust of their patients and partners.

Cost efficiency will remain a constant challenge, especially with the uncertainty surrounding healthcare reimbursement models. Practices will need to lean heavily on analytics and process optimization tools to identify inefficiencies and areas for cost savings.

In a panel discussion on the big headwinds orthopedic and spine ASCs are facing, Taif Mukhdomi, MD, a pain physician at Pain Zero (Columbus, Ohio), reiterated the importance of having a "streamlined" practice and leveraging market analyses to understand patient demand and price rates for spine surgeries and joint replacements. 

"I think if you're not growing, you're just stagnant or falling behind," he said. "Unfortunately in these times, long gone are the days where you can just be a single practitioner out here. The market won't support it. Your pay won't support it. Cost of living won't support it."

Strategic partnerships will become essential, enabling shared resources and combined expertise to maintain high-quality care without financial strain. Overall, the focus will be on creating a sustainable and resilient practice model that can adapt to the dynamic healthcare landscape; such a focus, Dr. Paul of Duly Health and Care said, will require better understanding and collaboration with payers.

"In my discussions with payers, when you really peel back the onion — yes, they want cheaper, better, faster — but their goals are really about mitigating risk," Dr. Paul said. "They want predictability, especially in spine. That's some of the reason they're being drawn to the ASCs; they've got a predictable measure on their cost. And to the extent a hospital system can be very, very predictable with the kinds of surgeons they have, if we can use technology to become very predictable and then market that to a payer, you're going to make your payer happy. You're going to be a very attractive system provider to them."

Sessions